Promptwatch vs Goodie for Monitoring AI Recommendations by Market and Question

How do they compare?

From Promptwatch's pricing page and guides, and Goodie's pricing page:

Why split recommendations by market?

Because the same question gets different answers in different places. Promptwatch's own guide gives the example of "best project management software," which surfaces a different set of brands in the US than in Germany. A single score across markets averages away exactly the places where a brand is winning or losing. A software company can look steady overall while it disappears from German answers and gains in Britain.

Promptwatch's advice, which holds for any tool, is to keep one monitor for each country, language and model combination, so the data never mixes markets. Goodie's country and location analytics serve the same purpose inside its plan limits. Why answers differ is covered in why LLM citations vary by country, language and topic.

Why split them by question?

Because recommendations for one question tell you little about another. A brand can be the first recommendation for "best CRM for real estate agents" and absent from "cheapest CRM with WhatsApp integration." Grouping questions by buyer need, such as category, use case, comparison, price and integration, shows which needs a brand wins and which it loses, and in which markets.

Promptwatch helps here with query fan-outs extracted from real answers, showing the searches assistants ran behind each question, and with modelled volume and difficulty for prompts. Goodie lets you save watchlists of competitor and category prompts, and ask its agent questions such as which prompts in Germany a competitor gained this month. More on each is in the Promptwatch review and the Goodie review.

How do costs compare for several markets?

The answer depends on how many markets and questions you need. Assuming each market's prompts count separately against the plan:

Per answer, Promptwatch Business delivers 42,000 responses a month for $579, about 1.4 cents each. Goodie Pro, if all eight engines run daily on 250 prompts, delivers about 60,000 for $999, about 1.7 cents. Goodie's price also includes strategist support, optimisation credits and, on Pro, SKU-level commerce data.

Which tool fits which team?

• Promptwatch suits teams that want to choose engines per market, need US state or city splits, and track many questions across several markets on a budget. Its collection from the assistants' own interfaces also matters for localised answers, since Promptwatch notes that API responses can differ from what the rendered interface shows.
• Goodie suits brands that want a fixed, broad engine set including Copilot, Alexa and Walmart's Sparky, shopping visibility by product, and hands-on strategist help, and whose markets fit within its plan limits.

How should you set up market-and-question monitoring?

1. Pick markets by revenue, not by where the website has a language version.
2. Write questions natively for each market, with local phrasing, currencies and competitors.
3. Group questions by buyer need, using the same groups in every market so results can be compared.
4. Choose engines per market: local usage differs, so check which assistants matter in each country.
5. Report a grid: markets down one side, question groups across the top, recommendation rate in each cell.
6. Review cited sources for the weakest cells, since local sources usually explain local gaps.

A wider approach to multi-country tracking is in how to track AI recommendations across countries and regions, and evidence over time in Promptwatch vs Scrunch for quarterly reviews.

Where does each fall short?

• Promptwatch: four models per plan; the pricing page and guide differ on which plans include state and city tracking, so check yours; content and crawler features rise with plan level.
• Goodie: country and language limits per plan; export and API access need Enterprise; engine set is fixed by plan.
• Both: a market's result is only as good as its native-language prompts.

We have not set up market monitors in either tool; this comparison draws on each vendor's pricing page and published guides.

What might this look like in practice?

Consider an illustrative project management software company, Morvquay, selling in the US, UK, Germany and the Netherlands. On Promptwatch Business, it ran one monitor per country with 40 questions each, in five groups: category, team size, industry, price and integrations. The grid showed Morvquay recommended in most US and UK category questions but absent from German integration questions, where answers favoured a local tool with SAP integration and cited a German software review site. Dutch results were strong on price questions. Morvquay published a German integration guide and pitched the review site, then watched that one cell of the grid.

What do people ask about Promptwatch and Goodie by market?

Can Promptwatch track by city?

Promptwatch offers US state and city targeting. Its pricing page lists it on Business, and a September 2026 Promptwatch guide says it is on every plan.

How many countries does Goodie Core include?

Two countries and two languages. Pro includes five of each.

Which is cheaper for four markets?

Promptwatch Business at $579 a month, against Goodie Pro at $999, for about 160 prompts.

Should one report combine all markets?

No. Report each market separately, then compare them side by side.